Tobey Maguire could return as Spider-Man, but his chance to return as Spider-Man after Spider-Man: No Way Home probably won’t be Spider-Man 4. But the MCU version of Spider-Man and Phase 4, in collaboration with Sony and Marvel Studios, paved the way for the Multiverse. The old Spider-Man crossover has become a reality.
Tobey Maguire and Andrew Garfield are both back in Tom Holland’s third Spider-Man film, No Way Home. Such a crossover already seemed unlikely, but it takes Maguire and Garfield to fly to the MCU’s Earth-616 and meet Holland’s Spider-Man. No Way Home was a standalone story, but it closed the door on Maguire or Garfield returning as Spider-Man versions at some point in the multi-faced Spider-Man movies.
Tobey Maguire’s return in No Way Home could mean a Spider-Man 4 starring Maguire, in addition to Sam Raimi directing Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness. It gives the impression that there is, but no sequel is guaranteed. Tobey Maguire returning as Spider-Man for the first time in Avengers: Secret Wars makes more sense. Slated for release in 2026, Avengers: Secret Wars is the final installment in the MCU’s multiverse saga and is to be multifaceted. Crossovers If the events of the “Secret Wars” comic book, especially the events of 2015, are not, “Secret Wars” could be Marvel’s most ambitious cinematic crossover yet.
For Secret Wars to be a worthy conclusion to the MCU’s Multiverse saga, potentially surpassing Avengers: Endgame in terms of scale, it needs to showcase Marvel’s legacy. But in Marvel’s entire cinematic history. With Tom Holland’s Spider-Man starring in two Avengers movies and Maguire and Garfield returning in No Way Home, it’s not too far-fetched to imagine the three Peter Parkers teaming up again in Secret Wars.
Why is Spider-Man 4 easier after Secret Wars?
We can’t rule out a Spider-Man 4 starring Tobey Maguire. But we’ll see if Sony’s deal with Marvel Studios on Spider-Man and his sidekicks says anything about running multiple Spider-Man franchises at once. It’s hard to say. However, No Way Home combines Elements of nostalgia and multiverse fantasy, so it’s easy to see how impactful the return of legacy Marvel characters like Maguire and Garfield’s version of Spider-Man would be. That said, it seems unlikely that Spider-Man 4 or The Amazing Spider-Man 3 will be before Secret Wars or the official announcement of the next MCU Spider-Man movie.
If the MCU wants Secret Wars to feature as many iconic characters as possible, continuing Maguire’s story in a standalone Spider-Man 4 before the end of Phase 6 of the MCU could complicate matters. Instead, a potential Spider-Man 4 could Serve as an end to Tobey Maguire’s Spider-Man after Secret Wars, saying goodbye to the characters after the multi-dimensional threat the heroes face. Spider-Man 4: Secret Wars also ensures that the sequel doesn’t overshadow spider-man I’s Dutch legacy ahead of the most Important MCU film in years.
